How to Have Impossible Conversations

Welcome, Fellow Travelers

Todays Book

How to Have Impossible Conversations
By Peter Boghossian

Summary Snapshot

"How to Have Impossible Conversations" by Peter Boghossian and James A. Lindsay provides useful tips for handling tough conversations. The authors suggest listening carefully, connecting with others, and asking open-ended questions to have meaningful talks about difficult subjects. The book shows how to turn arguments into cooperative discussions, allowing people to change their views without pressure or fighting.

• Conversations Are Collaborative: Impossible conversations can become productive when both parties collaborate instead of talking at each other. This approach encourages listening, questioning assumptions, and working together to find common ground, rather than engaging in verbal combat.

• The Importance of Listening: To change someone’s mind, you first need to listen to them. People are more likely to change their beliefs when they feel heard and understood, rather than when they are lectured or presented with facts. Listening creates a foundation for productive dialogue.

• Build Rapport First: Before diving into difficult subjects, build rapport. Friendly conversations are more likely to stay civil, even when disagreements arise. Rapport helps establish trust and creates an environment where both parties feel comfortable sharing their perspectives.

• Planting Seeds of Doubt: To change someone’s belief, you must first make them question their certainty. Ask questions that help the other person reflect on the limitations of their own knowledge. This approach makes them more open to reconsidering their views.

• Rapoport’s Rules for Productive Conversations: Follow four key rules for civil discourse: rephrase the opponent's position fairly, identify points of agreement, share what you've learned from their argument, and only then voice your disagreement. This ensures respect and mutual understanding during disagreements.

• Understand Moral and Social Beliefs: Not everyone forms their beliefs based on evidence. Many beliefs are shaped by moral or social considerations, making it difficult to change them with facts alone. Understanding this helps frame conversations in ways that can resonate with the other person's values.

• Use Logical Questions Instead of Facts: When evidence doesn’t work, try asking logical questions to expose inconsistencies in the other person's belief. By focusing on the internal logic of their views, you encourage them to reconsider their stance without feeling attacked.

• Minimal Encouragers: Small verbal signals, like “I see” or “Okay,” reassure the speaker that you’re actively listening. These minimal encouragers build trust and diffuse tension, making the conversation feel less combative.

• Mirroring Technique: Repeat the last few words of what the other person said in the form of a question. This shows you’re listening and encourages them to expand on their thoughts, giving you more insight into their perspective.

• Give Them a Graceful Exit: To avoid cornering someone in an argument, allow them to exit the conversation gracefully without feeling defeated. This tactic helps preserve their dignity and keeps the door open for future discussions.

• Start with Small Issues: Begin with easy-to-resolve issues in a conversation. Finding common ground on minor matters creates a positive atmosphere that makes it easier to navigate bigger disagreements later on.

• Understand the Unread Library Effect: People often overestimate their knowledge of specific topics. In conversations, help others recognize gaps in their understanding by asking them to explain things they think they know well, thus encouraging them to question their assumptions.

• Avoid Lecturing: People are more resistant to change when they feel lectured. Instead of delivering facts, create a dialogue where both parties are involved in exploring ideas. This makes the other person feel valued and open to considering different perspectives.

• Disarm with Empathy: Approach conversations with empathy, acknowledging the emotions behind the beliefs. Understanding where the other person is coming from emotionally helps to create a connection and prevents the conversation from becoming combative.

• Self-Generated Ideas Lead to Change: People are more likely to accept new ideas when they generate them themselves. Instead of telling someone what they should believe, guide them through a process encouraging them to arrive at their own conclusions.

Start learning AI in 2025

Everyone talks about AI, but no one has the time to learn it. So, we found the easiest way to learn AI in as little time as possible: The Rundown AI.

It's a free AI newsletter that keeps you up-to-date on the latest AI news, and teaches you how to apply it in just 5 minutes a day.

Plus, complete the quiz after signing up and they’ll recommend the best AI tools, guides, and courses – tailored to your needs.

Sign up to start learning.

• Conversations Over Debates: Treat difficult conversations as opportunities to explore and learn rather than win debates. Focus on building understanding and allowing the other person to articulate their views without feeling pressured to ‘win’ the conversation.

• The Power of Open Questions: Use open-ended questions to keep the conversation flowing and to prompt deeper reflection. These questions encourage critical thinking and allow the other person to examine their beliefs without feeling threatened.

• Know When to Stop Arguing: Recognize when a conversation has reached an impasse. Continuing to argue when no progress is being made can damage the relationship. It’s better to pause and return to the discussion later, when both sides have had time to reflect.

• Focus on Understanding, Not Changing Minds: The goal of a difficult conversation shouldn’t necessarily be to change the other person’s mind. Sometimes, simply understanding their point of view and allowing them to feel heard is enough to build mutual respect.

• Assume Good Intentions: Enter every conversation with the assumption that the other person’s beliefs are based on a genuine, if misinformed, desire to make sense of the world. This mindset helps prevent conversations from turning into attacks or accusations.

• Stay Calm Under Pressure: Stay calm and composed in emotionally charged conversations. Your demeanor influences the tone of the conversation, and remaining calm can help prevent escalation and encourage a more rational discussion.

• Avoid Making Assumptions: Don’t assume you know why someone believes what they do. Ask questions to explore the reasoning behind their opinions. This shows respect for their thoughts and creates a more open, inquisitive dialogue.

• Challenge Ideas, Not People: Focus on critiquing ideas, not attacking the person holding them. Personal attacks only escalate tensions, while challenging the belief itself opens the door for constructive discussion.

• Value the Relationship Over the Argument: Remember that maintaining a good relationship is more important than winning an argument. This will help keep conversations respectful and ensure that both parties feel valued, even if they disagree.

• Use Humor to Diffuse Tension: When used appropriately, humor can lighten the mood and ease tensions in difficult conversations. It helps break down barriers and can make it easier to approach sensitive topics with a sense of camaraderie.

• Know When to Walk Away: Some conversations may be too polarized to continue. Recognizing when it’s time to walk away preserves relationships and prevents unnecessary conflict. Agree to revisit the discussion later, when emotions have settled.

• Acknowledge Your Own Biases: Be aware of your own biases and how they affect the conversation. Acknowledging these biases helps you remain open-minded and encourages others to do the same.

• Don’t Force Agreement: Sometimes, the best outcome of a conversation is agreeing to disagree. Pushing for agreement can lead to resentment and disengagement. Focus instead on mutual respect and understanding, even if complete agreement isn’t possible.

• Create a Safe Space for Dialogue: Foster an environment where both parties feel safe expressing their views without fear of judgment. This will create the foundation for more productive and open conversations, especially on sensitive topics.

• Be Patient with the Process. Changing someone’s beliefs takes time, so don’t expect instant results. Instead, be patient with the process, allowing the other person to reflect on the conversation and come to their own conclusions over time.

What’s Next?

Start practicing these conversation techniques today. Focus on listening, asking thoughtful questions, and building rapport in your discussions. Approach difficult topics with empathy and curiosity rather than trying to win an argument. Doing so will foster meaningful and respectful conversations and open doors for greater understanding.

Amazon Book Link